My daughter in law wrote on her blog called Told Off in which she shared the concept of “killing silence.” I thought I would respond here, since she reads my blog.
She lives in an apartment. People in apartments are usually not very permanent and that, I feel, leads people to be more private. After all, it is not like the tenants are going to stay for a long time. Parting is painful, so people tend to keep to themselves. Younger couples tend to move more frequently than established households. Who wants to pack all that junk? Who wants to deal with kids whining because they will miss their friends? There is a reason why neighborhoods are different than apartment complexes, though apartments put people in closer proximity to each other.
I am an elevator talker, I talk to people in elevators. I wave and say hi when I am out for a walk. I stop and talk to neighbors, and it does not matter what race they are. Maybe it is because I grew up in Hawaii and suffered what discrimination feels like. I do not buy the “everyone is racist.” line that someone posted to Ki’s blog.
I try not to make small talk, I try to see how they are doing.
I love to discuss books that we have both read.
I grew up in a family where I had a lot of criticism. Thus, for self preservation I became a very contentious debater. I loved debate and making a good argument, and winning.
I run several yahoo groups. I kind of carried my defensiveness into my writing. Where I try to take away excuses.
All that said, in my old age I have come to realize that I hate debate, but love discussion. You can be all right and still be all wrong in a debate. You can win a debate with well constructed words that are wrong, only because the other guy is not quick on his feet, or does not know his stuff. You can construct a good argument and lose a friend.
Debate can bring a contentious spirit. It can destroy relationships and cause deep emotional hurt. It can be very offensive, uncivil, and ungracious. Debate really is not about truth, and I do not feel people can come to the truth through debate. So, I tend to not discuss things that I feel can lead to contentious debate anymore, or at least I try not to.
Last night’s devotional was on contention and debate. We did not pick the subject, it just happened to come up for that date in the book we are reading. We read a little each day. It is divided by the days of the year, and has thoughts to ponder. We do scripture study earlier in the day, but we close our day with a devotional thought to ponder. The devotional book we are using this year is When Ye Receive These Things: Daily Reflections on the Book of Mormon by Lloyd D. Newell and Robert L. Millet.
“July 13– There were many among them who began to be proud, and began to contend warmly with their adversaries…yea it was the cause of much trial with the church. For the hearts of many were hardened, and their names were blotted out, that they were remembered no more among the people of God. Alma 1:22-24
‘A hard lesson for us to learn is that whenever we engaged in argument or debate about sacred things, we are wrong. Persuasion and conversion to the truth come only through the quiet whisperings of the Spirit (I Corinthians 2:11-14), not through intellectual jangling or overmuch logic. It is possible for a faithful member of the church to become, essentially, anti-anti in their response to others who oppose our faith. In the process the church member forfeits the right to the gift of the Holy Ghost and places himself in spiritual peril. The risen Lord taught the Nephites that “he that hath the spirit of contention is not of me, but is of the devil, who is the father of contention, and he stirreth up the hearts of men to contend with anger, one with another.’ (III Nephi 11:29) We do not debate. We teach and we testify.”
With my dad, it did not seem to matter what side I took, it was always a debate. As I got older I tried to use his arguments and he debated those. I finally realized that he just liked to debate and win and it was not constructive.
I like to talk to people. I like to listen to people. I like to observe people. No one can accuse me of killing silence, well, anyone can accuse, but that is not the way I see what I do.
The key is, I do not sit here and wait for people to come to me. As an elevator talker, I am more inclined to disturb their bubble. If a home teacher or visiting teacher has not come, I confront them gently with a warm invitation. After all, they may be painfully shy. They may be suffering from a previous door shut in their face. They might be tired of setting appointments that others do not keep and may have lost heart. I give them a benefit of the doubt and open my door and my heart to them. I try to have friends that I can:
1) emulate
2) a few I feel comfortable with
3) a few that can benefit from friendship.
Yes, I spend most of my time in my comfort zone. However, I have friends that bring out my best, and I need that, we all do. I have a friend that is not active, and her husband smokes (and I am allergic to the smoke). I have friends that struggle with children inactive in the gospel. I do not give people 50 questions before I will befriend them. When I lived the apartment life, years ago, I would go out of my way to meet neighbors. I would invite them to dinner. It did not matter their race or religion. Some did not even speak English,but a little. Along with this, I would always look for and try to cultivate friendships with people of my own congregation that could lift me and I could lift. I would invite them to dinner, to go to the temple, watch their children while they went on dates, etc. That way, we young couples could strengthen each other.
So, “killing silence,” nope, I would not let it happen.