This was the 9th year that we did not engage in Trick or Treating. We have not established an alternative celebration. Sometimes we visit my mother-in-law and do a slide show, sometimes we went shopping. We went to Temple Square one year. But today we just had a quiet evening at home and did pass out candy to munchkins, and later went to a neighbor’s to see a movie, Arsneic and Old Lace. Our school did the play when I was in high school but I had never seen it. Slap stick! We have chosen not to dress up or decorate our home in “Halloween” theme. Yes I know about the Catholic Holy days of All Saints and All Souls Days. They were superimposed over the Celtic celebrations for Samhain (pronounced sow-in) that would then have his counterpart in spring with Beltaine. There were sacrifices of animals and people passed through the fire. I always felt it odd that I would practice a pagan day, that is also associated with darkness and paganism and the festivities that were brought over from it.
You might ask, do I do Christmas?
We do Christmas, I realize that it too was a Catholic Holy Day that was superimposed over a pagan celebration. We focus on the Savior. My children know who the real Saint Nickolas was and that he was a Bishop in Asia Minor. Most foreign countries celebrate St. Nickolas on 6 December. Yes we do a tree , but again the focus is uplifting and not about commercial symbols like santa and reindeer. We have a birthday dinner and party for Jesus and give him gifts. We make much of our gifts, look for ways to give and serve to others. We also have Christmas Evenings throughout the month when we are home, where we remember an episode from the life of Christ, sing religious carols, and read Christmas stories (always the Christmas Carol is part of this).
You might ask, ” and Easter ?”
We do Easter, yes. We have a devotional book for that which goes through the episodes of Christ’s life and we sing songs about him. Easter Bunny is not what we do on Easter Sunday. We have a basket of eggs, each egg has a symbol of Christ’s life and atonement and a scripture. We have a family dinner and we open each egg and think of the gifts of the Savior. My kids have a hide in plain site hunt, where we hide M&M and Jelly beans in our living room, on tops of books, edges of pillows, along the piano keys, in the corners of picture frames, etc. This is done, not on Easter Sunday. The egg represents the rebirth that comes with the resurrection. Yes I know that pagan cultures had spring rebirth rituals or traditions that include eggs. Ah, what came first the chicke or the egg? I say the chicken was created with the ability to reproduce. Likewise, pagan religions were created by those who chose out of true religion and not the other way around. So did some parent teach an object lesson as a family tradition to teach a truth, and then the object lesson became part of paganism? The answer would be speculative at best. Kind of like the interpretations of Indian history and the whys that the Pueblo Indians left the Mesa Verde area. We are great at collecting data, but the interpretation of data is limited by the lens or worldview, we use to interpret it. That goes for anything prehistory.
I see Halloween a little different than either Christmas or Easter. There is a focus on a wrong view of death and the after life on Halloween. Haunted houses, grave yards. Body parts hanging out from under car hoods. Witches on broom sticks flying into buildings, SPLAT. The going from house to house and expecting something for nothing, seeing how much booty one can gather. All that sugar! We even had a man in our neighborhood that had MS and knew he was going to die. So he ordered his casket. That was placed on the enclosed front porch of his trailor home for storage. He climbed in it on Halloween and sat up when people came to his front door and scared the kids out of their wits. I had a son dressed as the angel Moroni. When someone saw him come to the door she said she could not believe that someone would dress their child as a Ku Klux Klan member. My son responded, “I am not that, I am Moroni.” Ah, this comes to the avoiding even the appearance of evil. All of these things left me at ill ease. SO, we stopped practicing Trick or Treating 9 years ago.
There is plenty to celebrate that is good and uplifting. There is plenty for the imagination. I enjoy Christmas and Easter, the spiritual focus and the spirit that abounds. I just take issue with Halloween.